Clarence Thomas Concerned Over First Amendment Rights After Court Rejects Case

Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas issued a stark warning about government censorship Monday after the nation’s highest court refused to hear a challenge to a controversial California law requiring medical instructors to address implicit bias.

In a strongly worded dissent, Thomas accused a federal appeals court of undermining constitutional protections by allowing California to dictate what private instructors must teach. He warned that the ruling could open the door to even broader government control over speech.

“First Amendment protections do not give way simply because a State heavily regulates speech,” Thomas wrote.

The dispute centers on a California law passed in 2019 that requires continuing medical education courses to include instruction about implicit bias and its potential effects on patient care. The requirement took effect in 2022 and applies to courses used by doctors to satisfy the state’s continuing education requirements.

Dr. Azadeh Khatibi, a California ophthalmologist, joined the nonprofit organization Do No Harm in challenging the mandate. They argued that forcing private instructors to present the state’s preferred views on a disputed subject violates their First Amendment rights.

Khatibi maintains that implicit bias is not necessarily the primary cause of disparities in healthcare and believes instructors should have the freedom to determine what material belongs in their courses.

California defended its regulations as part of its responsibility to oversee medical education and protect patients. A federal district court dismissed the challenge, and the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that decision, concluding that courses approved for state credit qualify as government speech.

Thomas sharply rejected that reasoning.

Joined by fellow conservative Justice Samuel Alito, he argued that California cannot strip private instructors of their constitutional protections simply by imposing extensive regulations on their profession.

Thomas also raised troubling questions about where such government authority could lead.

He suggested that the same legal reasoning could potentially allow California to require medical instructors to promote government-approved positions on abortion or gender-transition procedures. He also questioned whether similar mandates could eventually be imposed on lawyers and other licensed professionals.

Those examples were hypothetical, but Thomas argued they exposed the broader constitutional danger of treating privately delivered instruction as government speech.

His concerns extended beyond California’s medical training requirements. Thomas criticized the Supreme Court’s own 2022 decision in Shurtleff v. Boston, warning that the legal test established in that case could allow lower courts to mistake heavily regulated private speech for speech belonging to the government.

He urged his colleagues to reconsider that standard before it allows further erosion of First Amendment protections.

Justice Neil Gorsuch also indicated that he wanted the Supreme Court to hear the California dispute, bringing the number of justices supporting review to three. However, at least four votes are required for the court to accept a case.

The November 16 decision leaves California’s requirement in place and allows the Ninth Circuit’s ruling to stand. It does not mean the Supreme Court ruled that the law itself is constitutional.

For Thomas, however, the consequences could extend far beyond one state’s medical classrooms. His dissent warned that allowing governments to classify private expression as their own could weaken a fundamental safeguard against compelled speech.

“A State cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny,” Thomas wrote, cautioning that the government-speech doctrine must never become a cover for censorship.

Although the Supreme Court declined to intervene this time, Thomas made clear that he believes the constitutional questions surrounding government-mandated speech are far from settled.

Leave a Reply

Proudly powered by WordPress | Theme: Baskerville 2 by Anders Noren.

Up ↑